As I have posted about before, there often is a tension between honoring an aging lawyer's past service and protecting the best interest of his or her client. This fable by Aesop describes one part of that tension.
The Old Hound
A Hound, who in the days of his youth and strength had never yielded to any beast of the forest, encountered in his old age a boar in the chase.
He seized him boldly by the ear, but could not retain his hold because of the decay of his teeth, so that the boar escaped.
His master, quickly coming up, was very much disappointed, and fiercely abused the dog.
The Hound looked up and said, "It was not my fault, master: my spirit was as good as ever, but I could not help my infirmities. I rather deserve to be praised for what I have been, than to be blamed for what I am."
Of course, in this tale, there is no ethical responsibility on the part of the hound to protect the best interest of his master, and capture the boar. If there were, what should the master do with the dog? If there is no ethical responsibility to capture boars, would your answer be different?
Comments